Further Explanation for the Removal of Super Pro Parties

  • Thread starter Thread starter cclient_libraries.remote_exception RemoteException
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
ATA_Grant said:
iJess_CrackThe_-CYP-_Whip said:
How about you actually listening to your community!? Start giving us some of the things we've been asking for forever... including iwars/beta wars, new rs gifts, new store items, pvp promos, different hunts (yes the pins hunt was different but the rest are basically the same). You want your lost revenue back? Give us a reason to spend money on this game again

For Beta Wars, please see my earlier comment in this thread.. In short though, as much as some players want them, the turnout when we bring them around isn't enough to sustain them.

For RS Gifts, we can definitely look into this. It's been far too long since we've added some.

For Store Items what kind are you thinking of?

For PvP Promos, what would this look like to you? What would it have you do and how would it work?

For Hunts, we've tried different formats. Pins were one, as are colour battles, daily leaderboards, and experimenting with different methods to obtain avatars/rewards.

Sustain them? We aren't asking for them to come back permanently but atleast occasionally

As for store item maybe a few new things... something after the crunk cup with decent stats for larger players... something cheaper for smaller players and a ec item

You've done pvp promo before... guessing you don't remember because it's been forever. Works like cat cafe promo... up the amount we make during pvp actions. I don't even care if you limit it to in wars only. And how about letting those of us who like to war benefit from hunts too??
 
ATA_Grant said:
John_Wick said:
Ok so you admit it's about Revenue 
The amount of parties being started has dropped?  DUH!!! Did you guys even bother to look at the time limit per SPP and how long it took to finish compared to Pro's? The basic percentage would probably be about the same. Maybe a little bit of decrease because SPP are 2-3 hours LONGER!! That just means you should get rid of Pro parties to. Because those take longer then normal parties.

SPP take longer the the payout is better then Pro's. Which helps everyone grow. And on top of it all, everyone who can't hit a Pro parties or even SPP are in sub clubs growing or learning the basics to this game for when they do get the adequate stats to hit Pro's they move up to the main club. But I'm sure you didn't factor in all that did you?

Basically all the  you fed us on this was REVENUE. Congrats. 

Yes revenue is a part of it. We're a business after all and making money is a necessary thing. It allows us to keep PIMD around for years to come.

That said, it is a balance and there are other factors that go alongside our considerations as well. Including the other metrics mentioned. It's not quite as simple as seeing a single number moving up and down, but rather how each piece impacts everything else as well. We understood Super Pro Parties would cause.a shift in these, but not one so drastic that it upset our game balance. We'll definitely continue to evaluate and see what changes we can make, and how we can bring about more fun to PIMD.

As we continue to evaluate progression, we'll know more and be better able to address the impact of a Super Pro style party and see what other alternatives may exist.

Ok an alternative could easily exist with the INCREASE pay of a Cat and Kini. Or as one of my fellow club members has talked about in our club chat a few times after SPP were released a SPCC and SPKini.

Also think of it think way. It's only a matter of time before more people started purchasing DN more and more. DN are probably one of the best features in the game. And then not be advertised right kills it.

But what do we know right? We're just the community.

When things are going right, ATA goes left.
 
Hurricane said:
Okay, sounds better than before. Yeah, maybe reducing the amount of drops that a super pro gives would've been a better idea to keep making money off cc so people can still get the tattoo pen, street art, etc. just a suggestion but you're right, you're a company and you do need to make money. Maybe you guys could do something better for all the community that plays, not only revolve on what makes money. ?

Reducing drops was something we thought about, though it wouldn't solve all of the issues at hand. We're looking at what we can do with the Super Pro Items and Avatars though, and hope to continue to make the game fun for our players.

Thanks for sharing, and understanding :)
 
ATA_Grant said:
This is again part of our discussion. We're trying to find a balance to reward those who have already worked towards the avatars, and also make them available to those who work towards then. Not sure what this means just yet, but its an active discussion in the office.
Nuhhhhhh
If you do decide to go with giving avatar for (2) items pls make it via key in store, as I want to keep my spro drop items instead of losing them and getting those Avas :?
 
I understand why you guys have removed the Spro parties, but what new parties or new feature will you introduce to replace them?

Also the items that dropped from the Spro parties could be moved to drop from the regular pro parties so players still have a chance at getting those avatars.

I really liked the idea of collecting the items to finally get an avatar that you can only really get from top 100. Now taking away the Spro parties kills the chances of (any of us without the high stat avatars) actually getting one.
 
ATA_Grant said:
You're definitely right. Fun is key. And I think the fact that most players stick around and continue to enjoy the game says a lot. Yes, this specific feature was removed, and while some fun went with it, it's going to allow us to ensure the games long term health, and to continue providing content for those very same players.
lol Can you not try to feed us with bs . You removed all the most interesting features (Wars, Ec transfer,Super pro, Jobs—you haven't updated this so basically it's gone—because of revenue. Now im sure you're gonna introduce a new party "CAT CAFE SUPER PRO" so we can buy cats and have the super pro at the end of the title, so you can have a balanced revenue. Have fun watching your game turn into a dating app or a pervert joint
 
-119- said:
I understand why you guys have removed the Spro parties, but what new parties or new feature will you introduce to replace them?

Also the items that dropped from the Spro parties could be moved to drop from the regular pro parties so players still have a chance at getting those avatars.

I really liked the idea of collecting the items to finally get an avatar that you can only really get from top 100. Now taking away the Spro parties kills the chances of (any of us without the high stat avatars) actually getting one.

We’ve got a few different ideas we’re looking into. Most are in early stages of planning, and so we don’t know how much things may change before they make it into the game, if they ever do.

That being said, what kind of things would you like to see in PIMD? What would make this game special or unique? What would you want to encourage growth?

With regards to the Super Pro items, that's definitely an option, among other things. I would say, however, that it's considered TBD at this moment.
 
John_Wick said:
ATA_Grant said:
John_Wick said:
Ok so you admit it's about Revenue 
The amount of parties being started has dropped?  DUH!!! Did you guys even bother to look at the time limit per SPP and how long it took to finish compared to Pro's? The basic percentage would probably be about the same. Maybe a little bit of decrease because SPP are 2-3 hours LONGER!! That just means you should get rid of Pro parties to. Because those take longer then normal parties.

SPP take longer the the payout is better then Pro's. Which helps everyone grow. And on top of it all, everyone who can't hit a Pro parties or even SPP are in sub clubs growing or learning the basics to this game for when they do get the adequate stats to hit Pro's they move up to the main club. But I'm sure you didn't factor in all that did you?

Basically all the  you fed us on this was REVENUE. Congrats. 

Yes revenue is a part of it. We're a business after all and making money is a necessary thing. It allows us to keep PIMD around for years to come.

That said, it is a balance and there are other factors that go alongside our considerations as well. Including the other metrics mentioned. It's not quite as simple as seeing a single number moving up and down, but rather how each piece impacts everything else as well. We understood Super Pro Parties would cause.a shift in these, but not one so drastic that it upset our game balance. We'll definitely continue to evaluate and see what changes we can make, and how we can bring about more fun to PIMD.

As we continue to evaluate progression, we'll know more and be better able to address the impact of a Super Pro style party and see what other alternatives may exist.

Ok an alternative could easily exist with the INCREASE pay of a Cat and Kini. Or as one of my fellow club members has talked about in our club chat a few times after SPP were released a SPCC and SPKini.

Also think of it think way. It's only a matter of time before more people started purchasing DN more and more. DN are probably one of the best features in the game. And then not be advertised right kills it.

But what do we know right? We're just the community.

When things are going right, ATA goes left.
Player appreciation week you did a 2x pvp for a couple days right? Pls think of pvp people too, it's not like anyone gonna bc off 2x :?
 
What we understand from your post is
1.you was loosing sales of cats EC and DNS
2. Oh there is no Two 

Give us the players what we want for a change not what you want

1. New party's
2. New pro party's
3. Yes super pro party's
4. Bigger clubs 110/120 members
5. New items in the store
6. New jobs
7. Wars for all those that want that
8. Drops from party's again not just cats or kinins but rare drops like ugly Squash
9. Some players want the old hunts brought back those that wasn't playing when you started hunts

These are not just my ideas but those of the players that I see posting in forums the ones that keep this game going
 
FATHER said:
ATA_Grant said:
You're definitely right. Fun is key. And I think the fact that most players stick around and continue to enjoy the game says a lot. Yes, this specific feature was removed, and while some fun went with it, it's going to allow us to ensure the games long term health, and to continue providing content for those very same players.
lol Can you not try to feed us with bs . You removed all the most interesting features (Wars, Ec transfer,Super pro, Jobs—you haven't updated this so basically it's gone—because of revenue. Now im sure you're gonna introduce a new party "CAT CAFE SUPER PRO" so we can buy cats and have the super pro at the end of the title, so you can have a balanced revenue. Have fun watching your game turn into a dating app or a pervert joint

Beta Wars, were just that, a Beta. Regular Wars still exist, and players can still do them just as they always could. At this point Beta Wars are not a focus of the game, for the reasons stated earlier.

EC Transfer was removed due to excessive abuse from players, and while convenient wouldn't be really a "Fun" part of gameplay.

Jobs, you're right it's been a long time. Can't promise anything but I'll talk to the devs about this one.
 
ATA_Mario said:
-119- said:
I understand why you guys have removed the Spro parties, but what new parties or new feature will you introduce to replace them?

Also the items that dropped from the Spro parties could be moved to drop from the regular pro parties so players still have a chance at getting those avatars.

I really liked the idea of collecting the items to finally get an avatar that you can only really get from top 100. Now taking away the Spro parties kills the chances of (any of us without the high stat avatars) actually getting one.

We’ve got a few different ideas we’re looking into. Most are in early stages of planning, and so we don’t know how much things may change before they make it into the game, if they ever do.

That being said, what kind of things would you like to see in PIMD? What would make this game special or unique? What would you want to encourage growth?

With regards to the Super Pro items, that's definitely an option, among other things. I would say, however, that it's considered TBD at this moment.


I don't know why y'all ask for our opinion, nothing we actually suggest in forums gets considered. As they say words are just words until one proves it with actions. And as developers ya ain't done nada. All you do is put stuff like ec trading and then remove them. Same to Spros. So really nothing we like seems to work with you all.
 
Why ask the players what we want if the answer is always no? We are the players and the ones that feed you every day. If we want beta/i wars(yes we, considering the support thread had over 100 pages) why not bring them back?
 
ATA_Mario said:
Hayley_in_Wonderland said:
ATA_Grant said:
For Beta Wars, please see my earlier comment in this thread.. In short though, as much as some players want them, the turnout when we bring them around isn't enough to sustain them.

For RS Gifts, we can definitely look into this. It's been far too long since we've added some.

For Store Items what kind are you thinking of?

For PvP Promos, what would this look like to you? What would it have you do and how would it work?

For Hunts, we've tried different formats. Pins were one, as are colour battles, daily leaderboards, and experimenting with different methods to obtain avatars/rewards.

You've tried different formats, but you do the same format over and over until you run it into the ground. Instead of taking the 20 different hunt styles you've come up with and rotating through them.

And you deleted my other comment so I'll make a couple points again.


1) why did you lie originally and say they were here to stay if they were always an experiment only?

2) You still haven't given us a valid reason besides your revenue drop. Obviously when parties are 6-9 hours long there will be fewer of them started than 2-3 hour parties. That's an absolutely ridiculous number to cite. As for a drop in the number of people partying, this last hunt was awful. Some enjoyed it but to most the avi's were hideous and the pins pointless and do nothing but make our showcase and gift screen a mess. This has nothing to do with the existence of super pros, and since more were added before you took them away, i'm guessing this problem is more recent.

3) this is the only major change you've made in years that was actually well received by the community, and you took it away, what kind of message do YOU think that sends your players?

With regards to the hunt formats, we do rotate through several formats including team battles, individual progressions, reward box openings, etc, as well as mixing and matching various hunt mechanics to provide variety. Every now and then we like to try coming up with new hunt formats to try like we did with the Dormlympics hunt that just ended. Sometimes the new formats work better and sometimes they don't. As we mentioned, any new feature in the game is treated as an experiment where we will evaluate what works and what doesn't. We do read and appreciate all the feedback given on hunt structures and take it into consideration when planning future hunts.

1) As we mentioned, it was originally our intention to keep the Super Pros around. However, as we continued to monitor the effects of the Super Pros, we made the decision to remove them.

2) As mentioned, we like to try new things every now and then to try and keep things fresh. We appreciate the feedback given and will keep it in mind for future hunts.

3) We don't like removing content either, but sometimes something that is well received may not necessarily be best for the health of the game. For example, if we were to make Cat Cafe permanently 5x, that would certainly be well received, but would it be a good thing for the game?

With regards to hunts, you really don't though. Every hunt has turned into top 10/100/500 etc for avatars with a regular key and a premium key for boxes 9/10 times. What happened to the original hunts where we collected stat items that combined only? Or the cute keys? Or the hunts with boxes that held avatars only that we haven't seen in over a year like the one spring hunt and game of thrones hunt? Or the VIP penguin and lion? Where exactly is the variety?

The difference is you can logically explain how 5x cc permanently would hurt the game. Everyone would be able to lcbc in weeks and have nowhere to go. Tutor market would get out of control. Game would be boring.

Now explain how super pros hurt the game. Other than your revenue. As I said - longer parties obviously means fewer. And if you can't just assume fewer people playing had to do with the pros. These are the only reasons you've given us besides revenue. That is telling your community you don't care if they enjoy the game.
 
I understand this is a business for you all but people that can't afford to keep buying cats get left in the dust. Finally with super pros other people had more of a chance at reaching the top reward tiers than just having to flash cats to get them. Taking away super pros and doesn't make me want to go buy cats, it showed me how selfish y'all can be. Not everyone can afford to keep buying cats all the time and super pros gave us a great alternative to earn a lot of drops without spending cash. Don't give the crappy excuse of separating players, yall do that on your own with those who can live in a cat club and those who can't. It comes down to y'all lost a huge profit and won't take the hit to satisfy your players. Without all of us playing your game you have no use to continue with the game. If should be a priority to please us. There would always be those who buy cats to insure their top 10 position or whatever so it's not like you completely lost your revenue. Finally there was something to be happy about and put time into and y'all took it away.
 
You're definitely right. Fun is key. And I think the fact that most players stick around and continue to enjoy the game says a lot. Yes, this specific feature was removed, and while some fun went with it, it's going to allow us to ensure the games long term health, and to continue providing content for those very same players.[/quote]

If you think that the reason people are sticking around is because we find this "fun", you clearly have not heard a single word anyone in the community we have built has said. (And yes I mean we, not you, we.) you may have given some framework and a pretty interface to play on, but realistically, the social aspect is pretty much the only shit we care about. And spps actually increased the opportunities for that. People stick with this game cause it's like a competition between friends. Not because hitting a damn repeat button 2000 times a day stimulates us. So cut the crap. Your greed is plain as day, our community is pissed about it, and you clearly don't give a damn cause your getting paid. End of rant. Have a nice fucking day.
 
ATA_Mario said:
-119- said:
I understand why you guys have removed the Spro parties, but what new parties or new feature will you introduce to replace them?

Also the items that dropped from the Spro parties could be moved to drop from the regular pro parties so players still have a chance at getting those avatars.

I really liked the idea of collecting the items to finally get an avatar that you can only really get from top 100. Now taking away the Spro parties kills the chances of (any of us without the high stat avatars) actually getting one.

That being said, what kind of things would you like to see in PIMD? What would make this game special or unique? What would you want to encourage growth?
Why are you asking your players what to do? Isn't it YOUR job to come up with ideas? Do you go to dinner somewhere as a customer and expect to be asked how the cook should do their job?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top