the lady had cosmetic surgery before they met. telling someone about cosmetic surgery that you've had shouldn't be of any importance IMo. from the looks of it dude thinks he's the best looking since sliced bread since he finds it hard to believe he made an unattractive child. he's shallow and the judge is worse. he shouldn't be a father, and he shouldn't be procreating.
But isn't the same as a transgender person not being open and honest in a relationship? I know that reproducing is unlikely in that scenario but he was mislead and I'm not at all condoning the way he's reacted to his child but i can see his point of view and could see why a judge found in his favour