I only read a few peoples comments, such as Ahlis because she's fucking awesome, but you mentioned the religion thing. Here in America there is supposed to be a separation of church and state, which I think means that religion has no bearing on laws and such.
Jesse, you mentioned that it's costly to kill them. It's also costly to keep them in jail for years at a time for them blatantly being messed up in the head. Think about it. They get tv, air conditioning, food, medical services, etc. that costs tax payers. Basically we are paying to house murders and child rapists.
Someone mentioned that the person could be innocent, and that is true, but if there is 100% no possible way it was anyone else.. I think the death penalty should still be in effect.
Nice thread. I like that I didn't see any trolls when I was skimming through comments but I may have missed them ..