Who am I? who am I? thats a dumb question. I am Dan.
And no matter what terms people agree to, if it is a group that seems good now, lame later, person should be able to leave whenever. Farming over a chance in choice is bad ethics. If I had a son who cost me tens of thousands to go to college for two years then decided... " I do not think I'm up for this anymore, I would like to do something else", yeah it would hurt nut choices like that should not result in me punishing him.
Same situation should apply to clubs, if you assume someone to always want to stay there then thats wrong. The way I see it, since the guy had already left before you should have expected them to possibly leave. And a consequence of farming is just bad policy, it is cruel and if I cared enough I'd farm bullies amd tyrants in this game. But heck, life is more important.