Poll: Is Kwanzaa a real holiday?

Status
Not open for further replies.
If I and my family commemorate the death of my chicken every year on the date of its death, that day is a holiday.
 
You have no right to tell me what I can and can't dedicate a holiday towards. If I choose to assign a day to commemorate or celebratr a specific thing then that is my right, and it is a holiday.
 
Kefo said:
If I and my family commemorate the death of my chicken every year on the date of its death, that day is a holiday.

No, Its a family tradition. Or personal tradition. Is a general group participating or is it just you/your family? Thats not a holiday.
 
Pale_of_Palii said:
Aphrodite said:
Just because a low amount of people celebrate it. Shouldn’t strip them to right to celebrate Kwanzaa.

Either you have not read anything I have written or you are purposefully interpreting my statements in an uncharitable manner. Anyone has the right to celebrate it. Anyone has the right to say this is a holiday-to-me or that this day is sacred to me and therefore I will celebrate it. I have no desire to stop people from celebrating Kwanzaa. They can celebrate the Festival of Captain Kirk (I just made that up) too if they so desire. Just because it is a holiday-to-them does not make it a legitimate, societal holiday. I celebrate certain holidays that some would consider illegitimate; that is fine. All men have a right to celebrate whatever they please, but it does not make their celebration a legitimate holiday.

The thing is.... it's a CULTURAL holiday, not a religious holiday or a national holiday, so therefore participation rate is bound to be lower because it falls in a completely separate category. This just sounds like a borderline racist, whiny thread of someone who thinks a holiday can only be considered one if they know ppl who celebrate it. Its not a "legitimate, societal" holiday clearly, because it was created specifically for African Americans to observe. Do AA's make up 100% or even a majority of the society??? No they dont. Not even 15%. Of course national/societal participation will be low because its not meant for the entire society to observe. Its a cultural, educational holiday with a background isnt driven by a specific religion or country affiliation, like Christmas or NYE. "Day of the Dead" is also a holiday in America that is cultural but its also religious, so it has more participation.
 
Dr. Maulana Karenga, professor and chairman of Black Studies at California State University, Long Beach, created Kwanzaa in 1966. After the Watts riots in Los Angeles, Dr. Karenga searched for ways to bring African-Americans together as a community. He founded US, a cultural organization, and started to research African “first fruit” (harvest) celebrations. Karenga combined aspects of several different harvest celebrations, such as those of the Ashanti and those of the Zulu, to form the basis of Kwanzaa. It’s a Cultural Holiday dedicated to African Americans. It’s not national, but it’s still a holiday. Get over yourself. ?
 
Aravis said:
I know we would eventually get this racist "poll". Kwanzaa is a holiday and that is final.

A) Poll is not racist.
B) You do not have the final say on the matter.

No, is my vote.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top