Kaw is their first, after so many similar apps they have to start finding different ways. Pimd is ata's second best, and avatars definitely help.
If by success we mean profit and amount of players, I'm going to have to disagree with what you said. Look at the pug hunt avatars for example, even I was considering spending money on one and I've only been back for a few days.
However, if by success you mean how "fun" it is, then definitely.
I know it was sarcastic but you still had a good point to be made just responding on a serious note I guess. I think it's an interesting topic.