My problem with KaW Zaft is that fact that you all tend to think everyone else is beneath you. That's about all I've observed because I hid under a rock there for the most part, lol.
As for gaw... Boy oh boy, history must really be written by the winner? In reference to the post on page 6 I believe, Zaft didn't make everyone else run away. This how things went down on gaw, and also why I refuse to believe the KaW ZAFT is as tight knit a family as they're trying to make everyone else believe.
In gaw there were 3 big networks early on... Infinitas, Zaft and IG. Eventually Infinitas split into No Remorse to start a huge war. So we were farming The mob, expanded and took on IG. Took no less than 24 hours of IG members being pinned that Zaft had to jump on that war train. Only reason the network had excelled early on was because it jumped in when it wasn't their war in the first place.
Zaft has been big for the simple fact that people join there, like Epi said, to be protected and talk shit. I've no doubt there are a core of good players, but there is a lot of extra baggage that would run away in a heart beat if a big enough war started.
That being said, I have had a few positive experiences with some ZAFT members and I respect them greatly. I respect the core of dedicated members, but nothing beyond that. Sandy comes to mind here. Great player and ruler.