What use to scare me when I was little was someone breaking in our apartment and either robbing or killing us... or a car crashing into the apartment since there was so many accidents on that corner...
What scares me now... A lot of things
Scariest movie when I was little? Chainsaw Massacre, maybe, and now not really a movie but Ghost Hunters and Ghost Adventures :3 They are shows I know, but I don't watch many movies.
When I was little, I always thought that if I didn't sleep with a blanket on, or a part of my body was out of the blankets, something was gonna eat me.
You can't technically call this a movie, but that freaking Maze game used to always scare the shit out of me.