Nice thread. Everybody seems to have a different opinion on what is good. Mine? If it isn't a 1) Pervy thread 2) Help me thread 3) I got silenced thread, it's usually ok with me.
Good and Bad are two illusions of life. Let's take an easy example. Superman. Most people agrees he is good. Do you think that, for a lambda criminal in the fictive world of superman, he is good? He use lethal powers against people who could be taken down more easily. If superman was real, his thing of fighting villains would become murders. Is he still good? What he tries to do is, for a majority of people, good but something good would be something that everyone agrees of its goodness. Same thing for the bad. A guy who steals to eat every days is bad for the shopkeeper but without it, he could die. Is it good or bad? It's both.
It's the same thing with threads. What is defined as bad by the readers might be defined as good by the original poster.