If I may, in my opinion the guy agreed to the terms in which the club proposed to him if he wished to be accepted in. I see the flaw but nevertheless he accepted it. It is their own club, therefore it's under their own terms. If you wish not accept it, then don't join.
An unbiased point of view from your fellow lurker,
Dextur.
I still think you guys should 1 v. 1 though just to sort out your differences.. Afterwards it is done with. We move on