I believe it was 2024 because it was the second or 3rd lucky box I can remember them releasing but it could've been from 2023, What I do know for sure though is they put re-release avis in the first few lucky boxes and the valentines lucky box that year had the base Heart On Her Sleeve Avatar in it. Which is why I think it's trashy they've now put this vip version in store for 99ec, We all know lucky boxes have trashy rates and it will have cost many people way more than 99ec to get her from lucky boxes..Tbh regardless of when it came out it's just some more very dissapointing behaviour from ata in my eyes. They could've picked bringback avis from a year where they hadn't made one of them a lucky box aviI believe it was actually 2023 and there are two other Valentine's lucky boxes that are more recent than the one Nereida mentioned.