I personally think that it should be thrown out. I mean, sure, they've killed someone and yes, they do deserve to be punished for what they did. But if you apply the death penalty to them, is that not just as bad as being the murderer him/herself?
Everyone deserves a second chance, even murderers. I'm not saying that you should let them just roam free after they killed someone, but to me, I think a life sentence in jail is already enough. And besides, not everyone who gets sentenced a death penalty is guilty. Some of them may be actually innocent. But by the time you figure out that they're innocent, guess what? They're already dead.