The people who support this new way of silencing are the same people who're willing to, or have already, broken rules.
The players who don't have a problem respecting those rules understand why this is a terrible decision.... Things won't change.
However, I ask the people who are okay with it this: you claim that these silences are good because the players who break rules aren't bothering the public... However, do those players truly deserve the right to communicate at all if they show that they can't respect the rules of the game? Clearly to have been silenced they have to have violated the rules in public chat channels, showing that they have a disrespect of the rules... And in my opinion those players don't deserve to communicate here at all.