Popular or not...
I don't think when a random person calls you popular, you're considered popular. It has to come from an ACTUAL popular person, not just some newb or forumer who walks by you. I consider it slightly biased and such, hence why I don't agree with the whole 'popular or not' thing.
But I, think all the veterans are popular. Hell, they're the vets for God sake.
As for nowadays... Sasu-chan, I guess you could be considered popular from what the majority of forums say.