People can't live forever. And that wasn't the point of that illustration. You can force someone to insure someone like that. If the man has already been a customer and then gets sick, insurance should do it's job. But if you require insurance to accept all people regardless of health, what motivation would anyone have to buy insurance until they get sick? That makes it where the insurance companies lose the money they need to provide coverage for the sick people. Obamacares solution is to make healthcare mandatory. That sounds good at first until you think about it. If insurance has to accept EVERY sick person, it costs them more money because they have to shell out the healthcare costs to so many people. That drives up the price of insurance of healthy people who are forced to buy something.