I've played all the ata games, except smash of course, and i can give accurate explanations on the flaws of each game.
Kaw: takes ALOT of in-depth strategy. Building layouts take alot of time to come up with, and there are so many different builds you can do. Hanzel builds, war hanzel builds, attack builds, war attack builds. Each build has its advantages and disadvantages and switching builds is nearly impossible unless you plan on losin a ton of cash. The Instances on kaw, epic battles, take more strategy than parties. You have to use items at certain points and have to keep certain attack bars at different health %s, and the crafting is a pain because you have to farm aqua and lava (havent played in a while, kinda forgot what the actual names are. Im pretty sure its aqua and lava)
Pimd: alot easier than kaw and more social. Less major sfw's going on (?no one here knows what a real sfw is until they've seen zaft vs tus vs code), and the game is flooded with little kids which makes gameplay annoying.
Gaw: worldchat had messages from several hours ago on it. Foruming wasnt done very much, only a few people really used forums. Honestly GaW was my favorite out of them all, wish it was more lively.
FC: this game was crap in every aspect, it was a knockoff of kaw.
Meego: no. Just no. Kill this game.