We've responded to this in the wrap up thread:
viewtopic.php?f=5&t=88148&start=110#p3168776
Hey guys,
So, what happened is the reward script did not hit everyone, and the Top 3000 and Top 5000 ended up being given to players that it should not have.
To make up for this, we'll be introducing a new reward tier.
Here's the updated changes:
Old Top 3000 - (actually given out to Top 5000) = Premium Avatars
Old Top 5000 - (actually given out to Top 10,000) = Prom Crown
New Top 3000 - will be getting a brand new avatar, that we will be running a design contest for.
The rewards script is still being run, so if you haven't gotten your items yet, please hold tight.
Our apologies for this derp, we hope you can forgive us, we working hard to get your items to you asap.