Hmmm, I don't think being of an alternative look defines who you are as a person, being alternative doesn't make you automatically a cheating whore.
Someone's look has no bearing on their personality at all. And as we age we grow and progress and most of the time a persons style changes as well.
In high school I was a alternative hippie type, then slowly went into what I am now which I don't believe has a term... My look changes up. My music has changed dramatically though. went from 90s alternative to rap. Maybe it's also the ages that you date I don't know what age you yourself are.... But party girls while fun...have that habit. or they're serial monogamists.
I really think it's probably the personality type you go for rather then the look.