I definitely understand your struggle. I personally believe in science, the big bang, and evolution. However, there are appeals and theories and beliefs that I find appealing in other, more belief based religions as well. The trick is to find what appeals to your beliefs, and to find how you interpret and understand it. You might make an example of Buddhism and the concept of reincarnation. Whole a Buddhist might view this through the lenses of Karma, and you soul returning in a new form. I see this as the reusing of molecules, compounds, and organic matter. So that what you are in this life, is in turn used to create new life.
Religion and belief does not need to be about lables and fitting into an outdated mold. Instead it is about 'Ultimate Concern'; what you value most in your life and not only the way it shapes your actions, but your view of the universe as well.
Just my 2 cents worth.