I don't think you can really put them side by side like that and judge them. They play such differing positions with both requiring a different set of skills. A 'true' football fan should be able to appreciate both of their skills, so I don't know.
On one hand, Ronaldo possesses a great quality of skill that Messi does not have. On the other hand, Messi has a wide range of skills, some of which Ronaldo himself does not possess.
But if we have to pick, I personally don't like Real so, I'm going to have to go with Messi.