Stats don't matter, it's all about activity. If you are active you will grow and your stats will increase. That is the base for how PIMD operates, that is why 'big stat' players usually demand more respect. Now saying that there are people like Spiny, Leothecool, spitfire, Meggy, Royale and others who have the respect of the community but are small stats.
But as a general rule of thumb, size is a good indicator of activity, and activity matters most. There will always be exceptions to the rule, but it's a good guide to go by.
Also trust me, as a retired mod, mods do have lives. We work, go to school, party, have social lives, form opinions on life, people, PIMD, etc. Mods can and do make mistakes. If a thread by a noob gets locked, there is probably a pretty good reason why. They probably wrote their thread in a fashion complaining about being silenced. If a thread by a veteran player, where the comment about being perma-silenced doesn't get locked, it is probably because they are using that thread to communicate with other players and NOT to complain about being perm-silenced. There is a very large difference. And yes, an LCBC/VIP player did have their thread locked last week because they were complaining about getting silenced, so it is not just noobs who have threads locked on them.