To me, love is all things.. It's acceptance, compromise, patience, forgiveness, understanding; an endless list really.. Ultimately, no matter the similarities, people are completely different; they've been brought up differently and had different experiences.
Love should be two people with complementary attributes, that bring out the best in each other, at the same time as having an acceptance of the worst in each other..
With those things in mind, I think everlasting love is possible, but in a more deeply respectful and caring way, rather than Hollywood's version of happily ever after..
That's not saying you can't have a lot of fun with each other and enjoy the romance either