Maybe like a buffy the vampire slayer themed gifts. Maybe like a stake and holy water and a cross necklace and a friendship ring. Omg anf mr gordo the stuffed pig ?? Just an idea
*Poofy Kitty( black and white furry ball look like with pink heart nose) *Every K-I-T-T-E-H should be POOFY, i Meow-Meow Yah!
*Music Box( A cute cat inside the box instead of a ballerina.) *Purr-fect gift for Kitty Purry, Meowsy!
*Easter bunnies( 7 cute rainbow bunnies like care bears, but CARE BUNNIES instead.) * Different Tags for 7 bunnies
Tarot card themed gifts. One card can be red boxing gloves meaning a fight or sfw to come. Another could be 2 hands holding meaning new relationship. Many possibilities for this idea.
A heart shaped pizza. For those who have a pizza my heart ️? Also love dices would make a nice rs gift. I don't think I've seen that on here.
A little Monster - Daddy's Little Monster (or Mommy's). A Dragon- You Light My Fire. A solid colored heart -ILY (maybe change the color of heart each month).