You do realize that even a thread posted in 'Off Topic' has a topic and straying from that topic will get a thread locked right?
Even a topic saying "Post random comments" is a topic of randomness. Once players start bashing others or trolling, the thread can be locked.
A thread that has been locked and then someone makes a new thread about the same subject can also be locked because it has already been locked before and it's an attempt to stop more trolling, more negative comments, and more off topic threads.
I don't have a problem with any mod, they are players and human like everyone else. Ski isn't the only mod that has had their silences lifted from a player, I'd be willing to bet money that its happened to every mod since the beginning of the game.