I disagree with you, Anya.
My "mother" spanked her kids with her hand/belt/other objects.
After awhile all it did was hurt, but you got used to it and usually we just didn't care what she did to us. She did other shit as well. But her violence toward her children did nothing to "discipline" us.
My father never once raised a hand to me, and yet I've never disobeyed him.
Fact of the matter is. No matter how violent my "mother" got toward me, it wasn't ever real discipline because I never took it as a lesson learned. It was just painful and abusive. Yet my father giving me a lecture and saying he was disappointed was more "discipline" than the violence of spanking or other things my "mother" showed.
My dad's side of the family also doesn't believe in spanking children, and they're children don't misbehave very often.
So to say hitting a child in ANY aspect is okay because it's "discipline"? I don't agree with. There are ways to manage and "discipline" a child without hitting them in any way, shape, or form.
Raising a hand/foot/object to a child's body body with the intent to punish/harm is abuse.
But that's just my opinion.