If you look at the time stamps, the first quote (written by Shadow) was written at 3:07pm and second quote written by Marie was at 3:09pm. The person calling him a liar posted at 3:10pm. I think the person posting about ARLTB not dropping probably made a typo error and was in the process of editing the post as once a person posts you have 5 minutes to edit.
Drops will be occurring at 20:00 GMT/12pm PST/2pm CST/3pm EST from now on per Emails from Support Parties switch occured POTD Hunt List Here is a party tracker so we can find party of the day Key Old Party Of The Day-NO LONGER DROPS Not Party Of The Day Party Of The Day Regular Parties NO LONGER DROPS Blue Plate Special Cat Cafe Pizza Pop (Art) All Roads Lead To Beer: MCM Prank Primer: illusion Counter Culture: ADF Fake Art 101: VH Factory Art: CCS Frisbee Follies: ofh Restless Keg Syndrome: VLV Arcade (Mis)fire: la Familia Art Starzzz: Riseagain DIY Tattoo: Guardians Pro Parties NO LONGER DROPPING 11/17 Unknown Being Checked Dumpster Dive: PMA Enjoi J-POP: Cult Classics First World Problems: Lil Familia No Hand Breaks!: QoH Draw Manga: AD Back Alley Debut: Venus Limo Luxury: OFH Hype Machine: Integrity Draw Manga (PRO): BN Cosplay Please (PRO): IT Fake Art 101 (PRO): matrix Noodle Express (PRO): Mob Anime Expo (PRO): tributes Counter Culture (PRO): elites Just Dance! (PRO): JD Back Alley Debut (PRO): WTC Limo Luxury (PRO): TSK Cabana Cool (PRO): Royale Enjoi J-POP (PRO): mysticals Arcade (Mis)fire (PRO): EX Big In Japan (PRO): CL Hype Machine (PRO): NL Parties Which Needs To Be Checked Afternoon Delight Anime Expo Big In Japan Cabana Cool Cosplay Please Fitspiration IT'S BROSTEP, BRAH! Just Dance! Noodle Express Skyhigh Party Wait-Listed Afternoon Delight (PRO) Art Starzzz (PRO) Blue Plate Special (PRO) DIY Tattoo (PRO) Dumpster Dive (PRO) Factory Art (PRO) First World Problems (PRO) No Hand Breaks! (PRO) Skyhigh Party (PRO) Wait-Listed (PRO)