There is two things I would like to point out that hasn't been on page one, and I haven't yet read the other pages.
Point number 1) what about those who're pinned straight from the start and have no time to even get one successful hit? And don't have doctor notes? Hmm?
Point number 2) with out inactive's, your active hitters would be hit, meaning you won't be able to plunder as much because of being hit and weaken by the opposite side.
Inactive's are a win/loss
Yes they may leak, but they take the heat away from your active hitters so they can make their inactive's leak. Both sides have them.