Fix the Rate my dorm XC

Are you sick of the alt dorms?

  • Yes

    Votes: 28 84.8%
  • No

    Votes: 2 6.1%
  • I don't vote

    Votes: 3 9.1%

  • Total voters
    33

Witchee

Well-Known Member
I adore the rate my dorm xc and seeing everyones creativity but find it has one major flaw to it that - all of the alt dorms.

There's so many dorms submitted that are very obviously for someone's alt to max assist their main's dorm. It keeps me from going into the voting section more than once per theme, and I'm sure it's discouraging for many others as well.

I'd like to see ATA fix this somehow. And I'd like to hear yalls thoughts on this and how to fix this. Maybe, just maybe, Ata will hear us too. 🙏

Here's what I suggest:

• I like the assist feature, it encourages me to check on my friends dorm. I don't think we should get rid of it just to discourage alt entries.

• A confirmation checkbox for your dorm to appear in the voting section. If left unchecked it can still be viewed from the friends list until checked.

• A larger minimum of items in dorm to submit an entry. Maybe only dorms with so many furni items can appear in the voting section.

• More / unlimited skip options so we don't have to vote on the dorms that obviously had no effort put into them.
 
Yup, major reason why I don’t vote is coz of the amount of alt dorms.
Like I don’t wanna vote between which empty ass alt dorm is better 😂😂
 
Yup, major reason why I don’t vote is coz of the amount of alt dorms.
Like I don’t wanna vote between which empty ass alt dorm is better 😂😂
Yesss exactly 😩 Let me vote for the dorms people actually put effort into.

With all the new puzzle box furni even the new players have a good chance at making cute dorms, but the alt dorms are so terrible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: L
Tbh from day 1 of its existence i knew it would go this way. And its a popularity contest. Has nothing to do with being on theme. People will vote for who they like best
 
Tbh from day 1 of its existence i knew it would go this way. And its a popularity contest. Has nothing to do with being on theme. People will vote for who they like best
It's no longer just a popularity contest. Now it's also for people running multiple alts to push themselves ahead. Giving 50 free likes to 'friends' is an AWFUL feature. Even if I had 5 friends on here, what makes the Dev things that they'll give the free votes to ME out of everyone else, assuming they even participate in the xc. I'm not even bothering to participate any longer because it's completely broken now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: C0w
It's no longer just a popularity contest. Now it's also for people running multiple alts to push themselves ahead. Giving 50 free likes to 'friends' is an AWFUL feature. Even if I had 5 friends on here, what makes the Dev things that they'll give the free votes to ME out of everyone else, assuming they even participate in the xc. I'm not even bothering to participate any longer because it's completely broken now.
I occasionally do it for a free pig and thats it. Its always been pointless to actul try get anywhere on it
 
I found the answer:

ATA revamp the sections of rate my dorm. Give us a "like/dislike" button for random generated dorms and our friends dorms and put this into its own section.

Then make a seperate section for voting on dorms. Make the dorms that appear in this section have to be from our liked, with a minimum of liking x amount of dorms (100 a good number maybe). You could even pair up the disliked dorms for us to vote on which we dislike the least, as this would at least put comparable matches together. Allowing our friends dorms do appear in the voting section would eliminate the need for the assist button, with the ability to vote on a singular dorm up to 5 times maximum.

These extra steps would definitely dissuade a lot of people from doing all that from an alt with no effort in creating a dorm to be rated, and allow us as players to vote on dorms we enjoy comparing.

Remove the "skip vote" option entirely and make it loop so we need to "like/dislike" so many before we can even vote for points, use all our vote points, and have to "like/dislike" again
 
  • Like
Reactions: 222
definitely needs to be fixed/revamped.

tired of seeing dorms that don't match the themes and they are up there sitting top 10. top 50. top 100. top 750. etc. also tired of seeing alts with 5 items making its way up onto LB. i think WHOLE dorms need to be put out. not just 5 items minimum (or whatever it is).. STOP ALLOWING PEOPLE TO USE ALTS. people are using them to hype their main up. not only that, some alts get rewarded too. giving people more furni keys, etc.
whole thing is unfair. rigged. and broken.
even tho it says max number of assists is 50? we can't even get up to that number?. so many people have told me "it says you reached the max number of assists"?!?!!? so make that make sense. FIX IT PLS🥲

we also NEED a dislike button to prevent these things from happening. not be forced to like one/ or pick a dorm.that ultimately just pushes dorms up in rankings. even the ones that aren't decorated fully, or on theme. what if both options are bad ones??☠️ we're forced to vote one up... personally, i don't like that.


dorms should be voted off LB. like i said, some dorms don't even match theme. and i enjoy seeing ACTUAL COMPETITION. dorms that people put effort into!!! i wanna see more of!! ~


make it so we HAVE TO like/dislike rooms. once you get X amount of likes (say 100 for example) you get ranked on LB top 100. while simultaneously, if you get X amount of dislikes (the higher it goes/the more dislikes) you get pushed down in rankings.

dislikes cannot push you off LB because of the likes you have putting you in good standing but they only push you down further. allowing GOOD COMPETITION into top 100, top 50, top 10 and so on. dorms that'll have more likes & less dislikes. they should be able to climb the LB ladder!!!!

i hope that makes sense lol
of if the idea of dislikes is too much. give us MORE SKIPS. UNLIMITED SKIPS.

SOMETHING needs to be done 🙏🏽 PLEASE
 
I think what it needs is to be coded better.

At a certain point, dorms with similar number of votes should be going head to head. That way we're truly voting on the best dorms, not just random dorms every vote.
 
Back
Top