Look guys. This is a thought subject but I will try to explain it.
Toney Maguire's version of spiderman is typically older in the 2000's so his character was/is different to Andrew Garfield's version of Spiderman.
Maguire is a 'nerd' or a 'science geek' and was therefore bound by the stereotypical look and behaviours expected of a 'science geek' at that time in society.
Garfield's character was created when society is more open and accepting about people not fitting onto just one stereotype or people not sticking to the expectations their stereotypes give to them. One example is Garfield's clothes - he dressed a lot more casual (usually a mix between attractive new York socialite crossed with skater slob) compared to the nerdy clothes Maguire wore before he was Spiderman.
Garfield also liked to skate board - which is not in the 'science geek' resume. The differences between Maguire and Garfield are more prominent becaise of societlq chanhes and advances in genre and stereotupical placement ergo I cannot and will not choose between the two.
Not even... Tobey was just a sucked as spider man. If you know spider man, he's a smart ass. He just plays around and makes fun of the bad guys. Tobey was a big emotional cry baby.