An avatar basically shows that you have payed for the game. You're more likely to be taken seriously if you have any avatar above the 5ec starting ones.
Gender-wise, I don't really notice a difference. I've used both female and male avatars and they basically just deter the same gender. Both male and female players are equally desperate and creepy.
Now, as for looks I don't even know what to say. People who take an avatar seriously aren't the people I would want to talk to anyway.