God dammit, I have a lot of pokemon games. But I'd say soul silver because the graphics are better and it brings back the older version pokemon. I got the Heart Gold version though, but SS is more popular. Although in HG, once your done defeating the game, then you can catch a LV. 70 Lugia which is a higher level than the HO-HO. Since the mascot of the game is the only difference between the two. And in SS its vice-versa.
I feel like such a nerd. Hooray.