WELP!? REVIEWS FOR CLUBS

Discussion in 'Questions/Feedback' started by HerValhalla, Jun 30, 2019.

?

Do you like this pitch of Welp Club Reviews?

  1. Yah, it's helpful..

  2. Nah, you're dumb...

Results are only viewable after voting.
Page 1 of 2
  1. Hey fellowPimD players, mods, devs and other uncategorized random people,

    So over the years of playing this game, I've come across a variety of clubs. Some are awesome, some are bad, some are absolute worst. But there's no way of identifying them for a person who's joining it for the first time from maybe a banner in campus or pub.

    My suggestion is we make WELP!? Reviews for Clubs that show up on Club wall, like the average rating of that club by people who have been there displays there and when you click the rating link you go to a page with individual reviews and ratings. Whole purpose is of making club owners and admins take this stuff seriously and for players to be able to dodge shady clubs such as Cat-Attractions from fooling them with what they advertise and book them for and what they actually give. I really hope that this idea is played around with and if not the whole suggestion, atleast a part of it is incorporated (such as like/dislike count with 90 letter max reason).

    Again... Everyone at ATA props to you for making this game so lovable and addictive also lots of love to the wonderful people who still somehow exist (as a rarity though) on this game here.

    Thanks
     
    #1 HerValhalla, Jun 30, 2019
  2. I get where you’re going with this, but I don’t think there’s a need for it at the moment.

    Perhaps a option to “like” the club would do better, as I can see a lot of unnecessary drama stemming from a comment section.
     
    #2 Day, Jun 30, 2019
    JoyBoy, HerValhalla, Alicia and 6 others like this.
  3. Try providing feedback directly to the owner?
     
    #3 Kefo, Jun 30, 2019
    HerValhalla likes this.
  4. Ooh there could be a club wall! For announcements and upcoming info and notes! Only owners and admins could post.
    (The club announcement changes and people miss important old announcements)

    Cool idea but then when i think of how crowded pimd has already gotten with stories, spinner, hunt box. Etc....makes me not want to suggest anything more
     
    #4 -Sodagirl-, Jun 30, 2019
    HerValhalla and Muschi like this.
  5. Honestly that or someone will just use alts to boost a club or pay others just to say nice things about it... so on and so forth
     
    #5 Sloth, Jun 30, 2019
    Muschi, HerValhalla, Jaidah and 4 others like this.
  6. I agree with you Day about this unneccassary drama. Keep it simple.
     
    #6 Gipsey, Jun 30, 2019
    HerValhalla likes this.
  7. I can just imagine angry trolls tryna ruin someones club rating with alts cause someone got butt hurt.
     
    #7 RoseMilkTea, Jun 30, 2019
    Muschi, HerValhalla and Maddi_Matsu like this.
  8. Basically this.

    I love what OP is trying to do, but I think the idea needs some revision.
     
    #8 Day, Jun 30, 2019
    Muschi and HerValhalla like this.
  9. Maybe like a Club Score but not voted on by players or members.

    Which essentially would be like what we have with LB already though...
     
    #9 RoseMilkTea, Jun 30, 2019
  10. Basically 🤧

    Or maybe just a thing based on activity? Like if you’re active for so many days you’d be able to vote the club up or down? I’m not sure though.
     
    #10 Day, Jun 30, 2019
    Muschi and HerValhalla like this.
  11. Word of mouth has always been helpful for me but this might verge on the whole defamation thing, which is against TOU. Of course, it isn't against an individual but it can certainly be a slippery slope.
     
    #11 Sherily, Jun 30, 2019
    Muschi, HerValhalla and RoseMilkTea like this.
  12. I dont think this should be implemented as this can be used to defame certain clubs which was previously stated goes against ToU as well.
     
    #12 Kaho, Jun 30, 2019
    Nemo and HerValhalla like this.
  13. Agreed - would be extra cool if there was a quicklink to all the clubs you've liked
     
    #13 _Kaname_, Jun 30, 2019
    HerValhalla likes this.
  14. I'm with most of the others here. I love the idea, but I can see it being abused. Maybe there's a way to somehow meet in the middle and come up with a way to rate clubs and take precautionary measures to prevent abuse.
     
    #14 Muschi, Jun 30, 2019
    HerValhalla and Alicia like this.
  15. Man, I’ve been thinking something like this for a while. Like button would work best. Imagine going into fw for either saying something negative or positive in a club rank comment. Lol
     
    #15 Alicia, Jun 30, 2019
    HerValhalla and Muschi like this.
  16. And I think there should be a way that only former or current members can rate the club. Maybe have a length of time they need to be in club too if possible. Like at least 24 hours?
     
    #16 Muschi, Jun 30, 2019
    HerValhalla and Alicia like this.
  17. Yes! I couldn’t have said it better. Mainly bc I couldn’t find the words lol but yeah, I think 24 maybe 48 hours. If you haven’t by then, you most likely won’t. Or maybe it wasn’t traumatic ( or Impactful rather) enough to remember later than that lol
     
    #17 Alicia, Jun 30, 2019
    HerValhalla and Muschi like this.
  18. Agreed, that’s what I figured was necessary to ensure that people don’t just put alts into their own club or others to effect rating.
     
    #18 Day, Jun 30, 2019
    HerValhalla likes this.
  19. Clubs can be awesome for years and fall apart in an afternoon. This idea wouldn't work
     
    #19 Angee, Jul 1, 2019
    HerValhalla likes this.
  20. Agreed haha drama would be there lol. But yeah anything to like rate club based on user experience rather than ranking by strength payout etc is good enough
     
    #20 HerValhalla, Jul 3, 2019
(You must log in or sign up to post here.)
Page 1 of 2